Technical guide

Gear Material and Heat Treatment Considerations

The load capacity of a gear depends as much on its steel and heat treatment as on its geometry. This guide compares the common gear steels and heat-treatment processes, explains how case depth is defined and measured, and shows how to specify material and heat treatment clearly on a drawing.

Extruder screws, helical gear and shafts suspended on a fixture above a pit furnace

Key takeaways

  • Material and heat treatment are chosen together: a case-hardening steel is meant to be carburized, a nitriding steel to be nitrided, and a quenched and tempered steel can also be induction hardened or nitrided.
  • Carburized and hardened gears give the highest tooth load capacity, but distortion normally requires gear grinding after heat treatment.
  • Nitriding and nitrocarburizing work at lower temperature with little distortion, but the hardened layer is much thinner than a carburized case.
  • A case depth value is meaningless without its criterion: CHD at 550 HV, SHD at 80 % of the minimum surface hardness, NHD at core hardness plus 50 HV (ISO 18203).
  • A good drawing states the steel grade, process, surface and core hardness, case depth with criterion and location, areas to be kept soft, and the inspection required.

Why material and heat treatment are decided together

A gear tooth must resist two different stresses: the contact (Hertzian) pressure on the flank, which causes pitting, and the bending stress at the root, which causes tooth breakage. A hard surface resists the first; a tough, strong core and a hardened root resist the second. No single steel delivers both without heat treatment, and each heat-treatment process works only with suitable steels. Choosing the steel first and the heat treatment later, or the reverse, is a common source of problems.

Load capacity calculations to ISO 6336 reflect this: the permissible contact and bending stresses in ISO 6336-5 depend on the material family, the heat treatment and the material quality grade (ML, MQ, ME), which covers cleanliness, forging reduction and process control.

Common gear steels

Case-hardening steels

Low-carbon alloy steels (about 0.15–0.22 % C) that are carburized, quenched and tempered. The core stays tough while the case becomes hard.

  • 16MnCr5 (1.7131): small and medium gears and pinions; limited hardenability, so the core hardness falls in larger sections.
  • 20MnCr5 (1.7147): slightly higher hardenability, a common choice for medium gears.
  • 18CrNiMo7-6 (1.6587): nickel-chromium-molybdenum steel for large modules, large sections and heavily loaded industrial gears; good core strength and toughness after hardening.
  • 20NiCrMo2-2 (1.6523): the European counterpart of SAE 8620, frequent on drawings of American origin.

Through-hardening (quenched and tempered) steels

Medium-carbon alloy steels that are hardened and tempered as a whole, usually before gear cutting.

  • 42CrMo4 (1.7225): the standard quenched and tempered steel for gears, shafts and pinion shafts; also suitable for induction hardening and nitriding.
  • 34CrNiMo6 (1.6582): higher hardenability and toughness for large cross sections and heavy shafts.

The strength obtained after quench and temper depends strongly on the section size, so the hardness or tensile strength should be specified for the actual diameter.

Nitriding steels

  • 31CrMoV9 (1.8519): chromium-molybdenum-vanadium nitriding steel, good core strength and a hard nitrided layer.
  • 34CrAlNi7 (1.8550): aluminium-alloyed steel that reaches very high nitrided surface hardness; the layer is harder but less ductile.

Quenched and tempered steels such as 42CrMo4 and 34CrNiMo6 can also be nitrided, with a lower surface hardness than aluminium-alloyed steels.

Forged, rolled and cast blanks

For highly loaded gears, a forged blank with sufficient reduction is preferred: it gives better soundness and grain flow than a blank cut from large round bar. Large rims are often forged or ring-rolled; very large gears may use cast steel rims or fabricated (welded) bodies with a forged rim, which require ultrasonic testing and weld procedures adapted to the steel. Cast iron (EN-GJL, EN-GJS) suits lightly loaded or slow gears. Worm wheels normally use a bronze rim, such as a tin bronze, fitted on a steel or cast-iron hub.

Heat-treatment processes for gears

Carburizing, hardening and tempering

The part is heated to about 900–950 °C in a carbon-rich atmosphere until carbon diffuses into the surface to the required depth, then quenched (often in oil) and tempered at low temperature, typically 150–200 °C. The result is a hard, wear-resistant case on a tough core, with favourable compressive residual stresses at the root. Carburized gears offer the highest load capacity, but quenching causes distortion, so precision gears are ground after heat treatment.

Carbonitriding is a variant in which nitrogen is added to the atmosphere; it is mainly used for smaller parts with shallow cases.

Nitriding

Gas nitriding diffuses nitrogen into the surface at about 500–570 °C, below the transformation temperature of the steel, with no quench. Distortion is very small, so parts can be finish-machined before treatment. Cycles are long and the hardened depth is shallow, usually a few tenths of a millimetre. A thin compound layer (white layer) forms at the surface; for gears it is often limited or removed, because it can chip under high contact stress.

Nitrocarburizing

Ferritic nitrocarburizing adds nitrogen and carbon at about 560–590 °C in shorter cycles. It produces a well-defined compound layer with good wear, scuffing and corrosion resistance and a shallow diffusion zone. It suits shafts, timing gears, dies and extruder components more than heavily loaded power-transmission gears. It must not be confused with carbonitriding.

Induction hardening

Only the surface layer is heated by an induction coil and quenched immediately. Small gears can be spin hardened as a whole; large gears are hardened tooth by tooth, either along the flanks or around the full contour including the root. Root hardening matters for bending strength: a flank-only pattern leaves the root unhardened. Typical steels are 42CrMo4, 34CrNiMo6 and C45.

Quench and temper

Hardening followed by tempering at a higher temperature gives uniform strength through the section with moderate hardness. It is the final condition of many large gears, shafts and pinion shafts, and the preparatory condition before induction hardening or nitriding.

Process comparison

Process Typical steels Typical surface hardness Hardened depth (order of magnitude) Distortion Usual finishing
Carburizing + hardening + tempering 16MnCr5, 20MnCr5, 18CrNiMo7-6 58–62 HRC CHD about 0.3–3 mm, depending on module Significant Gear grinding
Gas nitriding 31CrMoV9, 34CrAlNi7, 42CrMo4 About 600–900+ HV, depending on steel NHD about 0.2–0.8 mm Very low None or light finishing
Nitrocarburizing 42CrMo4, 34CrNiMo6, many others Compound layer, high hardness Compound layer of a few hundredths of a millimetre plus a shallow diffusion zone Very low None
Induction hardening 42CrMo4, 34CrNiMo6, C45 About 50–58 HRC SHD about 1–5 mm, depending on method Moderate, local Grinding if precision requires
Quench and temper 42CrMo4, 34CrNiMo6 About 250–350 HB Through the section (section-dependent) None after gear cutting Gear cut after heat treatment

These are typical industrial ranges for orientation, not specifications. The values for a given part depend on the steel, the section size and the process.

Case depth definitions

Case depth is determined from a hardness traverse on a cross-section, measured in Vickers from the surface inwards. The depth is the distance at which the hardness falls to a defined limit. ISO 18203 now covers all three families of hardened layers; it replaced ISO 2639 (carburized cases) and ISO 3754 (flame and induction hardening), and its nitriding criterion matches the one long used in DIN 50190-3. Older drawings often still cite these earlier standards.

  • CHD – case hardening depth (German Eht): depth at which the hardness reaches 550 HV, for carburized or carbonitrided and hardened parts.
  • SHD – surface hardening depth (German Rht): depth at which the hardness reaches 80 % of the minimum specified surface hardness, for induction or flame hardening.
  • NHD – nitriding hardness depth (German Nht): depth at which the hardness reaches the core hardness plus 50 HV, for nitrided and nitrocarburized parts.

The test load, the measuring location (for example at mid-height of the tooth flank, and separately at the root), and whether the value applies before or after grinding must be stated, because each of these changes the result.

Distortion and grinding allowance

Quenching after carburizing changes the geometry: bores grow or shrink, thin rims become oval, the helix angle can change slightly and runout increases. Precision gears are therefore cut with a grinding allowance on each flank, typically a few tenths of a millimetre depending on module, size and expected distortion, and ground after heat treatment.

Two consequences follow. First, the specified CHD must remain after grinding, so the case is produced deeper to include the stock removed. Second, uneven stock removal or aggressive grinding can locally reduce the case or cause grinding burn; temper etch inspection to ISO 14104 is the usual check. Areas that must stay soft (threads, bores to be machined later, keyways) are protected before carburizing or machined after carburizing and before hardening.

How to specify material and heat treatment on a drawing

A clear drawing note avoids interpretation. Include:

  1. Steel grade by EN designation and material number, and the blank form (forging, bar, casting) if it matters.
  2. Process: carburized, hardened and tempered; gas nitrided; induction hardened (flank or contour); quenched and tempered.
  3. Surface hardness with scale and range, for example 58–62 HRC.
  4. Core hardness or strength for case-hardened and through-hardened parts, at a defined location.
  5. Case depth with criterion, location and condition, for example “CHD 550 HV1 = 1.2–1.6 mm at mid-flank, after grinding”.
  6. Soft areas and permitted compound layer for nitriding.
  7. Inspection and documents: hardness traverse on the part or on a representative test piece of the same steel and section, and the material certificate type (for example EN 10204 3.1).

Approximate steel equivalents

EN designation Material number AISI/SAE (approx.) Former AFNOR (approx.)
16MnCr5 1.7131 5115 16MC5
20MnCr5 1.7147 5120 20MC5
18CrNiMo7-6 1.6587 No direct equivalent 18NCD6
20NiCrMo2-2 1.6523 8620 20NCD2
42CrMo4 1.7225 4140 / 4142 42CD4
34CrNiMo6 1.6582 4340 (close) 35NCD6
31CrMoV9 1.8519 No direct equivalent –
34CrAlNi7 1.8550 No direct equivalent –
C45 1.0503 1045 XC45 / C45

Equivalents are approximate: chemical ranges and hardenability bands are not identical. When a drawing gives a foreign or obsolete grade, check the composition and the required properties before substituting.

How TSIRIKOS can help

TSIRIKOS has its own heat-treatment department next to its machining shops in Piraeus, so gears and shafts can be cut, heat treated and ground in one sequence. The processes include gas carburizing with oil quenching and tempering, gas nitriding, nitrocarburizing, induction hardening and quench and temper, with steels selected for each application. See our heat treatment services, industrial gears and shafts and pinion shafts, read the guide on common causes of gear failure, or send us your drawing with the material and heat-treatment requirements.

Technical FAQ

Which surface hardness and case depth can TSIRIKOS achieve?

Gas carburizing with oil quenching and tempering reaches 55–65 HRC depending on the carburizing programme, with a case depth (CHD) of up to 2.5 mm; gas nitrocarburizing reaches 55–62 HRC depending on material. Each load is matched to the working dimensions and load capacity of the furnaces, so send the part dimensions and weight with your request.

Does TSIRIKOS heat treat parts made by other companies?

Yes. Heat treatment is offered as a service in its own right, including for example the hardening of aluminium extrusion dies. Send the drawing, the steel grade and the required hardness and depth for review.

Can 42CrMo4 be carburized?

It is not intended for it. 42CrMo4 already contains about 0.4 % carbon; carburizing would make the case brittle and the core too hard. For 42CrMo4, the usual routes are quench and temper, induction hardening or nitriding. For a carburized gear, choose a low-carbon case-hardening steel such as 18CrNiMo7-6 or 20MnCr5.

Is carburizing always better than nitriding?

No. Carburizing gives a deeper case and the highest contact and bending strength for heavily loaded gears, at the cost of distortion and grinding. Nitriding gives very low distortion and good wear resistance, suitable for finished gears, moderate loads, internal gears that are difficult to grind and wear parts such as extruder components.

What case depth should I specify?

The required depth depends on module, load and the size of the gear. A frequently used starting point for carburized gears is roughly 0.1 to 0.2 times the normal module, confirmed by a load capacity calculation to ISO 6336. Always state the criterion, the location and whether the value applies after grinding.

Request for quotation

Case-hardening, through-hardening and nitriding steels; carburizing, nitriding, nitrocarburizing, induction hardening and quench and temper; CHD, SHD and NHD definitions; distortion, grinding allowance and drawing notes.

Please attach your technical drawings and specifications to your email.