Key takeaways
- Reverse engineering is the practical route when the OEM part is obsolete, the drawing is missing or the lead time is unacceptable for the plant.
- A worn part is not a drawing: dimensions must be reconstructed from unworn surfaces, the mating parts and standard fits, not copied as measured.
- For gears, the tooth count, span measurement over k teeth, tip diameter, helix angle and the working centre distance together define the gear data.
- Material and heat treatment cannot be seen: chemical analysis and a hardness profile are needed when the part is loaded or case hardened.
- The customer approves the new drawing before manufacture and remains responsible for the right to reproduce the part and for its operating conditions.
When reverse engineering makes sense
Many plants run machines that are twenty, thirty or forty years old. When a gear, shaft or bush fails, the original manufacturer may no longer exist, may no longer support the model, or may quote a delivery time that is out of proportion with the cost of a stopped line. In these cases the replacement has to be made from what is available: the failed part, its mating parts and whatever documentation survives.
Reverse engineering is usually justified when:
- the OEM part is obsolete or the equipment manufacturer has left the market;
- no drawing exists, or the drawing on file does not match the installed part after years of modifications;
- the OEM lead time or price is not compatible with the outage, especially for critical single-line equipment;
- the original part keeps failing and the plant wants a replacement with a reviewed material or heat treatment;
- a spare must be kept in stock for a part that has never been documented.
It is usually not the best route when the OEM can supply quickly at a reasonable cost, when the part is subject to type approval that a copy cannot obtain, or when the sample is so damaged that its geometry cannot be reconstructed with confidence.
The reverse engineering process, step by step
1. Collect all available information
Before measuring, collect everything that narrows the unknowns: machine make, model and serial number, the nameplate of the gearbox, the position of the part in the assembly, old drawings or parts lists (even partial), the bearing numbers, and the operating data (power, speed, duty). If the mating gear or the housing is available, it is often more valuable than the failed part itself, because it is usually less worn.
2. Measure the part and compensate for wear
A worn part must not be copied as measured. Dimensions are taken preferably on unworn or lightly loaded surfaces: the ends of the face width outside the contact area, the non-loaded flank of a gear that turns in one direction only, the tooth root, shoulders and undercuts. Functional dimensions are then reconstructed:
- bearing seats and bores are referred to the bearing that is fitted and to a standard ISO fit (for example k6 or m6 on a shaft seat, H7 or J7 in a housing), not to the worn diameter;
- keyways, splines and threads are matched to their standard (DIN 6885 keys, DIN 5480 or ISO 14 splines, ISO metric or inch threads);
- lengths and shoulder positions are checked against the assembly, especially when shims or spacers are involved;
- inch or metric origin is identified early: a dimension of 50.80 mm is far more likely to be 2 inches than 50.8 mm by design.
3. Determine the gear data
For a cylindrical gear, the essential measurements are the number of teeth, the tip diameter, the span measurement over k teeth (base tangent length) for two consecutive values of k, and the helix angle and hand. The difference between two span measurements equals the base pitch, from which the module (or diametral pitch) and pressure angle can be identified among the standard combinations, such as 20° metric modules or 14.5°, 20° and 25° inch systems. The span measurement itself then gives the profile shift, and the working centre distance of the housing confirms that the gear pair closes correctly.
The helix angle can be measured on a gear measuring machine, derived from the lead, or checked by rolling the gear with its mate. For bevel and worm gear sets, the pair must be treated together: spiral bevel gears depend on the cutting method and the machine settings, and a worm wheel must match the worm’s axial module, number of starts and lead angle. These cases need more engineering time and, wherever possible, both members of the set.
4. Identify the material
The material of a loaded part cannot be judged by eye. The usual methods are:
- chemical analysis by optical emission spectrometry (OES), which measures carbon and the alloying elements; portable X-ray fluorescence (XRF) identifies alloying elements but cannot measure carbon, so it cannot distinguish all steel grades;
- hardness measurement at the surface and in the core;
- metallographic examination of a section when the heat treatment or the microstructure is in doubt.
The result is translated into a current standard grade (for example an EN steel such as 18CrNiMo7-6 or 42CrMo4) that is available and suited to the heat treatment.
5. Determine the heat treatment
The hardness profile from the surface into the core tells which process was used. A carburized gear shows a high surface hardness that decreases gradually over a deep case; an induction-hardened gear shows a hardened contour or flank with a sharper transition, and sometimes an unhardened root; a nitrided part shows a very hard but thin layer. Measuring the depth at a defined limit hardness gives the case depth to be specified on the new drawing (see our guide on gear materials and heat treatment).
6. Create the drawing and obtain approval
The measurements are turned into a complete manufacturing drawing: dimensions and tolerances based on function, gear data table with an accuracy grade (ISO 1328 or DIN 3962), surface roughness, material, heat treatment with hardness and case depth, and inspection requirements. The drawing is sent to the customer for review. Open points, such as a doubtful fit or an improved material, are decided at this stage, not after manufacture.
7. First-article inspection
The first part is inspected against the approved drawing and, where possible, compared with the original: dimensions, hardness, roughness and tooth form, then a trial fit or a contact pattern check with the mating gear. For series spares, the approved drawing becomes the reference for future orders.
What can be recovered from a sample
| Information | Typical method | Reliability |
|---|---|---|
| Main dimensions, fits | Measurement on unworn surfaces, bearing and fit standards | Good if reference surfaces survive |
| Gear module, pressure angle, profile shift | Tooth count, span over k teeth, tip diameter, centre distance | Good for cylindrical gears; mating gear helps |
| Helix angle and hand | Gear measuring, lead measurement, rolling test | Good; needs care on large gears |
| Material grade | Chemical analysis (OES), hardness | Good; XRF alone is not sufficient for steels |
| Heat treatment and case depth | Hardness profile on a section, metallography | Good, but destructive on the area tested |
| Original design loads and safety factors | Not recoverable from the part | Must come from operating data |
Limitations and risks
Reverse engineering reproduces geometry and material; it does not reveal the original designer’s intent. Keep these limits in mind:
- Design loads are unknown. If the original failed because it was undersized, an exact copy will fail the same way. Operating data and the failure mode (see our guide on common causes of gear failure) should be reviewed before deciding to copy or to improve.
- Wear hides the nominal geometry. Heavily worn or deformed parts leave more dimensions to engineering judgement. The mating parts and the housing reduce this uncertainty.
- Hidden features are easy to miss: tip and root relief, crowning, residual stress from shot peening, special surface treatments or balancing requirements.
- Intellectual property and approvals. The customer is responsible for confirming that the part may be reproduced. Parts in lifting equipment, pressure equipment, rail vehicles or classed ships may need approval by the OEM, a notified body or the classification society.
- Destructive testing may be needed for material and case depth. With a single sample, plan the analysis before cutting anything.
What to send with your request
- The failed part, or clear photos with a scale, if shipping is not yet possible.
- The mating gear or adjacent parts, if available.
- Machine make, model, serial number and the position of the part.
- Any drawing, sketch, parts list or nameplate data, even incomplete.
- Operating data: power, speed, torque or duty, and the observed failure.
- Required quantity, urgency and delivery location.
For gears, our guide on how to request a quote for a custom gear lists the data in detail.
How TSIRIKOS can help
TSIRIKOS manufactures to customer drawings or from samples; standard catalogue parts are not its business. For a part without a drawing, the sample is measured, the gear data and fits are reconstructed, a drawing is prepared for your approval and the part is then manufactured in our workshops in Greece, with in-house gear cutting, grinding and heat treatment. See our reverse engineering service, industrial spare parts and manufacturing from drawings, or send us your request with photos of the part.
Technical FAQ
Can TSIRIKOS make a part without a drawing?
Yes. The company has long manufactured to customer specifications from a drawing and/or a sample; a worn or broken original part can serve as the basis for a new drawing and a replacement part.
Who approves the dimensions before manufacture?
You do. The drawing created from your sample is sent to you for review and approval before material is ordered and machining starts. Questions about fits, tolerances or heat treatment are clarified at this stage.
Which measuring equipment is used for reverse engineering (3D scanning, coordinate measuring machine, gear measuring)?
Depending on the part, samples are measured by 3D scanning, on a coordinate measuring machine (CMM) and, for gears, on a gear measuring machine for profile and helix. Chemical analysis of the material is carried out in our in-house laboratory.
Will the material analysis damage my sample?
Surface hardness checks and spark spectrometry leave only small marks. A full hardness profile through a hardened case requires a cut section, which destroys that area of the part. If you have only one sample that must remain usable, say so in your request so that the analysis can be planned accordingly.
Can the replacement be better than the original?
Often, yes. If the original failed early, the material, heat treatment or a dimension can be reviewed together with you once the failure cause is understood. Any change is shown on the drawing and approved by you; the responsibility for the operating conditions stays with the equipment owner.
Is it legal to copy an OEM part?
This depends on the part, the country and any design rights or contracts involved. The customer is responsible for confirming that the part may be reproduced. Parts in certified or classed equipment may also require approval by the OEM, the notified body or the classification society.